Filetype PDF | Posted on 20 Sep 2022 | 3 years ago
Authentication
digital resources
178x Filetype PDF File size 0.27 MB Source: www.kornferry.com
THE REAL TRUTH
ABOUT PERSONALITY
ASSESSMENT
Fact Sheet
Personality has become trendy. Online channels, social media, and dating apps buzz
with quick personality surveys and fun results to share with friends.
But, as assessment becomes more widespread, so more than 100 years, there are many different
does the opportunity for misinformation. Korn theories to choose from, including Jung’s theory
Ferry would like to share some truths about of personality types and the HEXACO model of
personality assessment, based on our deep personality.
understanding of the well-established science of
personality. Our approach to personality The Five Factor Personality Model or “Big Five”
assessment is rooted in science, fairness, and has been clearly established as a premier
inclusivity. These 11 true statements will clear up personality framework that is relevant around the
some common misunderstandings. world. Although the Big Five constructs are
sometimes described or conceptualized
1. Everyone has a personality differently, they are most commonly known as
Stability (or Neuroticism), Agreeableness,
Personality is an important part of who we are. It Openness to Experience, Extraversion, and
involves our characteristic patterns of feeling, Conscientiousness. The Big Five framework is
thinking, and behaving, including how we typically based in the lexical tradition, which assumes the
interact with others and approach different important descriptors differentiating people will
situations. These patterns are shaped by nature be represented in natural language. This
and nurture. Although personality reflects framework is a descriptive conceptualization of
relatively stable aspects of “who people are,” personality with narrow traits nested within
personality characteristics, or traits, can be broader traits known as super factors. It differs
changed slowly over time as people are motivated from psycho-dynamic theories such as those
to take on new challenges. For example, an developed by Freud and Jung. The scales in the
introverted person who wants to build networks primary Korn Ferry trait measure are based on the
or exert more influence may consciously reach out “Big Five.”1
to meet new people and make an effort to speak
up. As this example shows, personality
characteristics differ from skills or capabilities.
2. Models of personality have stood
the test of time 1. Like the "Big Five" model, the Korn Ferry trait scales are intended to
assess personality traits within the normal range, not to diagnose any
Building a personality assessment begins with mental disability or medical condition. Clinical personality batteries
choosing what to measure. This means picking a are used to assess psychological disorders and should not be used in
model or approach to thinking about personality. the workplace.
Since personality has been formally studied for
1 © Korn Ferry 2021. All rights reserved.
Fact Sheet
3. Good personality assessments are If used appropriately, personality assessments can
supported by strong research be used fairly at work for many purposes,
including:
“Pop psychology” quizzes are everywhere, Self-awareness, including how a person likes to
claiming to report insights on who you are relative approach their work, interacts with others, and
to popular characters or groups in books and handles stress and challenges.
movies. They are designed for fun and offered for
free on the internet. We enjoy the parts that seem Personal development, including leadership
relevant and tend to overlook the rest, so they development.
may seem generally accurate and meaningful.
But personality assessments used for research Team building by increasing awareness of self
and job-related insights need to meet well- and others.
established professional standards. These include Succession planning to determine who is ready
ensuring the reliability, validity, accuracy, and for leadership roles.
fairness of results. A test is reliable if results are
consistent and dependable. A test is valid if it Identification of people with high potential for
really measures what it intends to measure. No future leadership opportunities.
personality assessment is perfect, but good ones
offer repeatable and valid feedback to all. Creating career paths and determining
readiness and fit for the next step.
When robust personality insights are wanted, an
assessment should always be grounded in Hiring, based on fit with, and motivation for a
science. Look for assessments which offer strong given role.
psychometric-based properties, clear technical In many roles, personality is a noteworthy
documentation, and even independent reviews or predictor of job performance. Combining
endorsements by third parties such as the British personality information with data from other
Psychological Society (BPS). assessments, interviews, and resumes offers
Korn Ferry offers reliable and valid personality powerful insights to inform decisions about
assessments. Additional information about our people at work.
personality trait measure and scales, including 5. It’s important to pick the right
reliability and validity information, can be found in
our technical manuals. report for the situation
4. Personality assessments have many When determining the right fit, sometimes an
work-related purposes occasion calls for a custom-tailored suit, with
carefully measured dimensions. Other times, a
Personality is measured for a range of close approximation—small, medium, or large t-
applications, and in many different contexts, shirt—is easier and more effective for the
including therapy, vocational and career situation. Personality feedback can come in a
counseling, school psychology, and the workplace. carefully measured fit or a more general fit, and
Researchers have spent decades investigating which approach is preferred depends on the
how personality affects behavior at work. It is now purpose.
well-established that personality traits influence a Reports from personality assessments should be
variety of work-related outcomes, including aligned with both the intended use of the
satisfaction, engagement, performance, and more. assessment, as well as the target audience. For
Which traits matter most varies somewhat from example, if an assessment is being used to recruit
job-to-job and across organizations. Certain for a particular job, the feedback reports for the
personality traits tend to predict some work- hiring manager should provide detailed
related outcomes better than others. Personality information about candidates’ personality profiles.
assessments carry a considerable degree of If, on the other hand, an assessment is designed
legitimacy in diverse contexts and are often to provide general insights about strengths and
expected by clients and human resources development opportunities, then the report
practitioners seeking assessment services for their should share highlights to maximize self-
organizations. awareness for the participant.
2 © Korn Ferry 2021. All rights reserved.
Fact Sheet
6. Simple feedback can help people 8. Personality assessment response
understand themselves options have trade-offs
One common way people enjoy receiving their Information about personality can be collected in
personality feedback is through typologies or a variety of ways. Here are a few commonly used
categories, what Korn Ferry calls “Personas”. formats, each of which has pros and cons.
These descriptions are broad like a small, medium,
or large T-shirt rather than a tailored suit. They The relatively simplistic dichotomous test format
offer a starting point for people to understand offers two alternatives for each item. A person is
themselves and give a general frame of reference presented with a single statement and asked to
for how they are similar to or different from select "True" or "False" or “Yes” or "No". This
others. response format is fast, but sometimes requires
completing many items. Some people don’t enjoy
Personas should not be viewed as an exact or just having two response options to choose from.
complete description of a person’s personality,
and should not be used for talent selection, Assessments with Likert-type scales give multiple
identification, or comparison purposes. They are response options that are ordered on a
designed to be descriptive. They are not precise continuum. For example, people are given a
enough to predict job fit or performance, for statement and asked to choose one of five
example. response options, ranging from “Strongly
Disagree” on the left to “Strongly Agree” on the
7. Benchmarked personality feedback right. People often prefer to have multiple choices,
can inform work-related decisions but sometimes differ in the extent to which they
use the full range of responses. Additionally, some
Making decisions about people at work is people may answer as they would like to be,
consequential and reporting from personality rather than how they truly see themselves.
results for this purpose needs to be more precise The forced-choice response test format asks
and tailored, like the custom-fit suit. This typically participants to rank their choices according to
involves comparing a person to what good looks which are most like them to least like them. This
like, or what is required for success through approach reduces the chances that a person will
benchmarking and norms. Norms reflect the be able to manipulate their responses to produce
average score of a specific population, and a high a result that they think is ideal. Here is an example:
or low score is defined by the distance from the
average or “norm” for that population. In addition,
it is important to take into consideration the
specific demands of the job. This can be reflected
through benchmarks, or a profile for what success
looks like.
Consider the use of a personality assessment in a
recruiting context. Let’s assume that the open
position is a customer service representative at an Items that force a participant to choose can be
insurance company. The report should show how scored in different ways. Forced-choice item
a job candidate’s results compare to both 1) the response theory (FC-IRT) methods are the gold
norm group, and 2) the customer service job’s standard for maximizing insights from scores.
target profile or “benchmarks” for personality Korn Ferry’s primary trait self-assessment uses
traits. The ideal profile for this position might FC-IRT.
include higher than average scores on personality
traits such as empathy, adaptability, trust, and 9. Well-designed personality
humility, particularly in comparison to other jobs assessments are fair
requiring less interpersonal interaction, such as an
accountant or data scientist. Personality assessments are often recognized for
Remember that personality is only one of the being fair and equitable. When used properly, they
many attributes which contribute to success at offer objective, impartial insights useful for
work. Better prediction can be achieved when informing workplace talent decisions which are
combining personality insights with information free from the conscious and unconscious biases
on additional job-related characteristics. that can affect human judgments, such as
3 © Korn Ferry 2021. All rights reserved.
Fact Sheet
recommendations or manager nominations. Put or more traditional approaches, fairness should be
simply, appropriate assessments should not show evaluated by scientists and third-party experts. An
differences where differences do not exist. In algorithm is simply a function that tells a
addition, assessments must be deployed in line computer what to do to generate a particular
with best-practice guidelines. For a hiring process outcome. AI-derived algorithms can be fair, and
to be fair, many factors must be considered in not all assessment scoring algorithms are created
addition to having a well-designed assessment. using AI.
These include applying an inclusive, equitable, and 11. Use best practices for the best
consistent recruitment process across all results
candidates.
We are committed to helping clients remove Like any product or tool, there are right and
bias from talent decisions. wrong ways to use personality assessments. Korn
Ferry follows and recommends these best
We write our assessments using equitable and practices for using assessments in the workplace:
inclusive language and evaluate for readability. 1. Transparent. The purpose of a personality
We’ve worked with experts to ensure our assessment needs to be clearly stated, and
assessments meet standards for accessibility. informed consent must be obtained from each
person who takes one.
We routinely examine our assessments for 2. Fair and equitable. Personality assessments
group differences to support and uphold
professional and legal standards. can offer objective talent insights. Robust
personality assessments are built to be fair,
We work with expert legal counsel to review equitable, and inclusive for all participants.
our methods of evaluating adverse impact. 3. Psychometrically sound. Only personality
We are transparent about the validity of our assessments that are grounded in science are
assessments and can provide technical robust. Ensure there are technical manuals
manuals and psychometrician support at any which document the reliability and validity of
time. any personality assessment. A quick quiz on a
social media platform is almost certainly not as
We work closely with our clients to ensure they scientifically sound as an assessment you may
are using the appropriate assessments. be asked to take for work, even if some of the
We regularly conduct research on our questions seem similar.
assessments to ensure that they are related to 4. Applicable. The personality assessment must
outcomes such as work engagement, be “fit for purpose.” In other words, the
organizational commitment, job performance, assessment and its reporting should be applied
and company performance. for the uses for which it has been developed
We offer local validation studies for a fee when and validated.
clients are interested in more specific Personality assessment is powerful because
validation. people like learning about themselves and others.
Well-designed and fairly used personality
10. Artificial intelligence (AI) scoring assessments are a valuable tool for a variety of
should be monitored workplace applications. We hope these 11 core
truths help people understand, evaluate, and use
The term ‘AI’ is often used to describe scoring personality assessments to maximize the potential
computations that have been developed by a of people and organizations.
computer. There have been instances in which AI-
developed recruitment algorithms have
inadvertently trained themselves to be biased
against certain groups, leading to skepticism
about this technique. It is important to check AI-
developed algorithms for inappropriate group
differences. Regardless of whether the scoring of
a personality assessment is developed through AI
4 © Korn Ferry 2021. All rights reserved.
no reviews yet
Please Login to review.
