203x Filetype PDF File size 0.38 MB Source: web.stanford.edu
Macroeconomic Dynamics, 5, 2001, 101–131. Printed in the United States of America. MDINTERVIEW ANINTERVIEWWITH MILTONFRIEDMAN Interviewed by John B. Taylor Stanford University May2,2000 “His views have had as much, if not more, impact on the way we think about monetarypolicyandmanyotherimportanteconomicissuesasthoseofanyperson inthelasthalfofthetwentiethcentury.”ThesewordsinpraiseofMiltonFriedman are fromeconomistandFederalReserveChairAlanGreenspan.Theyarespoken from a vantage point of experience and knowledge of what really matters for policy decisions in the real world. And they are no exaggeration. Many would say they do not go far enough. It is a rare monetary policy conference today in which Milton Friedman’s ideas do not come up. It is a rare paper in macroeconomics in which some economic, mathematical, or statistical idea cannot be traced to Milton Friedman’s early work. It is a rare student of macroeconomics who has not been impressed by reading Milton Friedman’s crystal-clear expositions. It is a rare democrat from a formerly communist country who was not inspired by Milton Friedman’s de- fense of a market economy written in the heydays of central planning. And it is a rare day that some popular newspaper or magazine around the world does not mention Milton Friedman as the originator of a seminal idea or point of view. Anyoneofhismanycontributionstomacroeconomics(orrathertomonetarythe- ory, for he detests the term macroeconomics) would be an extraordinary achieve- ment. Taken together they are daunting: • permanent income theory; • natural rate theory; • the case for floating exchange rates; • moneygrowthrules; • the optimal quantity of money; • themonetaryhistoryoftheUnitedStates,especiallytheFedintheGreatDepression, nottomentioncontributionstomathematicalstatisticsonrank-ordertests,sequential sampling, and risk aversion, and a host of novel government reform proposals from the negative income tax, to school vouchers, to the flat-rate tax, to the legalization of drugs. Address correspondence to: John B. Taylor, Department of Economics, Stanford University, Stanford, CA 94305- 6072, USA; e-mail: johnbtaylor@leland.stanford.edu. c 101 °2001CambridgeUniversityPress 1365-1005/01 $9.50 102 JOHNB.TAYLOR MiltonFriedmanisaneconomist’seconomistwholaidoutaspecificmethodology of positive economic research. Economic experts know that many current ideas and policies—from monetary policy rules to the earned-income tax credit—can betracedtohisoriginalproposals.HewontheNobelPrizeineconomicsin1976 for “his achievements in the field of consumption analysis, monetary history and theory and for his demonstration of the complexity of stabilization policy.” Preferringtostayawayfromformalpolicy-makingjobs,hehasbeenaskedforhis advicebypresidents,primeministers,andtopeconomicofficialsformanyyears. It is in the nature of Milton Friedman’s unequivocally stated views that many disagree with at least some of them, and he has engaged in heated debates since graduate school days at the University of Chicago. He is an awesome debater. Heisalso gracious and friendly. Bornin1912,hegrewupinRahway,NewJersey,whereheattendedlocal public schools. He graduated from Rutgers University in the midst of the Great Depressionin1932.HethenwenttostudyeconomicsattheUniversityofChicago, where he met fellow graduate student Rose Director whom he later married. For nearly 10 years after he left Chicago, he worked at government agencies and research institutes (with one year visiting at the University of Wisconsin and one year at the University of Minnesota) before taking a faculty position at the UniversityofChicagoin1946.HeremainedatChicagountilheretiredin1977at the age of 65, and he then moved to the Hoover Institution at Stanford University. I have always found Milton and Rose to be gregarious, energetic people, who genuinely enjoy interacting with others, and who enjoy life in all its dimensions, from walks near the Pacific Ocean to surfs on the World Wide Web. The day of this interview was no exception. It took place on May 2, 2000, in Milton’s office in their San Francisco apartment. The interview lasted for two-and-a-half hours. Ataperecorderandsomeeconomicchartswereonthedeskbetweenus.Behind Milton was a floor-to-ceiling picture window with beautiful panoramic views of the San Francisco hills and skyline. Behind me were his bookcases stuffed with his books, papers, and mementos. Theinterview began in a rather unplanned way. When we walked into his office Milton started talking enthusiastically about the charts that were on his desk. Thecharts—whichhehadrecentlypreparedfromdatahehaddownloadedfrom the Internet—raised questions about some remarks that I had given at a conference several weeks before—which he had read about on the Internet. Aswebegantalkingaboutthecharts,IaskedifIcouldturnonthetaperecorder, since one of the topics for the interview was to be about how he formulated his ideas—andaconversation about the ideas he was formulating right then and there seemed like an excellent way to begin the interview. So I turned on the tape recorder, and the interview began. Soon we segued into the series of questions that I had planned in advance (but had not shown Milton in advance). Wetookonebreakforaverypleasantlunchand(unrecorded)conversation with his wife Rose before going back to “work.” After the interview, the tapes were transcribed and the transcript was edited by me and Milton. The questions and answers were rearranged slightly to fit into the following broad topic areas: • moneygrowth,thermostats, and Alan Greenspan; • causes of the great inflation and its end; INTERVIEWWITHMILTONFRIEDMAN 103 • early interest in economics; • graduate school and early “on-the-job” training; • permanent income theory; • return of monetary economics; • fiscal and monetary policy rules; • use of models in monetary economics; • use of time-series methods; • real business-cycle models, calibration, and detrending; • natural rate hypothesis; • role of debates in monetary economics; • capitalism and freedom today; • monetary unions and flexible exchange rates. Keywords: Permanent Income Theory, Natural Rate Hypothesis, Floating Ex- change Rates, Monetary Policy Rules, Money Growth MONEYGROWTH,THERMOSTATS,ANDALANGREENSPAN Friedman: [Referring to the charts in Figures 1 and 2] I thought that you’d be interested in these charts. Don’t you think it’s as if the Fed has installed a new and 1 improved thermostatic controller in the 1990s! FIGURE 1. Year-to-year change in U.S. real M2 and real GDP, 1960.1–1999.3. (Source: Milton Friedman, February 20, 2000.) 104 JOHNB.TAYLOR FIGURE 2. Velocity of M1, M2, M3, and log trends based on data from 1959–1980, annual data, 1959–1999. (Source: Milton Friedman, April 30, 2000.)
no reviews yet
Please Login to review.